Line Ratings - True or False

by Gus Mansour
(UK)

More of a query than anything else. Are we all using line that is too strong for our rods?

I was reading about Honryu fishing on a Japanese website, Google translate is wonderful if eccentric, and came across a conversion formula from Line size to lbs breaking strain. They were of the opinion that the correct strength could be calculated by multiplying the Japanese size by 4. So a rod rated for a number 1 line was suitable for 4lb test tippet.

By diameter a Japanese number 1 is 4x but you would be hard pressed to find 4x that was only 4lb test in Europe or the US. Chris seems to agree with the strength conversion as he wrote on the Kyogi page that the 3 line rating meant it could cope with a maximum of 12lb line.
Esoteric tackle over here sells the Fujino Turbo tippet in size 1.2 – the maximum for most tenkara rods and they give a breaking strain of around 4.5lb.

So again are we all using line that is too strong for our rods? More importantly, am I going to break my beloved Soyakaze by using 3 lb tippet instead of the (roughly) 2 lb 7oz that a .6 rating should convert to.
At this point I wish I could afford to buy a whole bunch of rods and actually test how much pressure they took before they failed.

Personally, I would appreciate standardised strength ratings for JP and x sizes. There is a very wide variation in the actual specifications of tippet. 5X should be 0.8JP or 0.148mm. I have seen tippet rated 5X with claimed diameters ranging from 0.14 – 0.17 and strengths from 2lb to just over 6lbs. I definitely feel that manufacturers of fixed line rods should list the rods capability based on line strength rather than diameter.

Thoughts anyone?

“The bitterness of poor quality remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten” - Benjamin Franklin

"Be sure in casting, that your fly fall first into the water, for if the line fall first, it scares or frightens the fish..." -
Col. Robert Venables 1662

As age slows my pace, I will become more like the heron.

We've all had situations where seriously chewed up flies kept catching fish after fish after fish. It is no sin to tie flies that come off the vise looking seriously chewed up.

Seriously, all the hooks sold on TenkaraBum.com, whether packaged as loose hooks or incorporated into flies, are dangerously sharp. Some have barbs, which make removal from skin, eyes or clothing difficult. Wear eye protection. Wear a broad-brimmed hat. If you fish with or around children, bend down all hook barbs and make sure the children wear eye protection and broad-brimmed hats. Be aware of your back cast so no one gets hooked.

Also, all the rods sold on TenkaraBum.com will conduct electricity. Do not, under any circumstances, fish during a thunder storm. Consider any fishing rod to be a lightning rod! Fishing rods can and do get hit by lightning!